Who is A Part 1

Who is A

Now that A may have name aka Charles it has made me come to new theory on the identity of A. First I'm not sold on A being Jason's twin the two boys do look very similar, but they don't look like there the same age. It can't be Andrew because Jason is way older than him and with that said it can't be Lucas either. So the baby in Mrs D. arms could be Bethany since she is suppose to be one or two years older than the Liars. My only problem with the twin theory if you had a twin wouldn't you remember that I do think its someone tied to both Alison and Spencer. So here is my theory PLL writers are obsessed with Alfred Hitchcock the one movie we have seen played out on the show over and over again is Psycho. In case you never seen the movie I will give you quick summary Norman Bates dresses up as his mother and the kills the women that come to stay there. In Norman's mind he has not killed anyone his mother did, but we find out in Psycho 2 that the woman who raised him was not his mother but his aunt in the end he kills her to. So that gets me to thinking why does A have to be a brother or sister why can't he or she be there cousin. Which leads me back to Charles what if after Mrs. D had Allison she started to see the change in Charles and sent him away while Allison was still a baby maybe to go live with her mother. Charles over time becomes obsessed with Alison Mrs.D sees the jealousy and the anger displayed by Charles and  decides to put him Radley to get him some help. Now the next part of my theory is going to sound real crazy but, what if there is no Bethany and Charles and Bethany are really the same person. We don't know what Bethany looks like only what she sounds like only picture we have seen is that of Sara Harvey. So Charles in his mind he is Bethany Mrs.D she has excepts him but Mr. D can't take the  fact hat his nephew/son is different he gets angry at Charles. They send him away but not to Radley at first maybe he did something to hurt Allison and remember the story of the twins. Well Charles then takes on Bethany and obsession with Allison grows worse so bad that now Mrs D is afraid of him. So when Radley calls and tells her he escaped she becomes worried for the safety of Alison. Charles did have a first victim Toby's mother he was the one who pushed her off the roof and Mrs. D got it covered up because she was on the board.

The Truth About Mother